Winnie Jayne
Enrolled Agent-led tax planning and returns
SAMPLE REPORT
S Corporation Election Analysis
Prepared for Morgan, a fictional fitness studio owner in Richmond, Virginia · Report date: October 15, 2026
- Single, rents, standard deduction
- Health insurance: $7,200 a year
- 401(k): $24,500 a year from 2027
- Four contract coaches
Sample report. Morgan, the studio, and its numbers are fictional, so this shows the format, not what you would save. Tax figures use 2026 federal and Virginia rules as a full-year illustration for 2027, rounded to the nearest $10. Not tax advice for your situation.
The short answer
Yes. Elect S corporation status starting January 1, 2027.
- File the S corporation election (Form 2553) in December 2026.
- Pay yourself $60,000 a year through payroll, starting in January.
- Make Virginia's pass-through entity tax (PTET) election when profit tops about $112,000.
Short on time? This box and your timeline in section 6 are what matter most.
1Where you stand now
Your LLC is taxed like a sole proprietorship today, and it qualifies to elect S corporation status.
Today
- Profit goes on Schedule C of your federal return and on your Virginia Form 760.
- Self-employment tax applies to about 92% of your profit.
- Virginia treats a single-member LLC the same way.
Ready to elect
- One owner
- You're a U.S. citizen
- One class of ownership, no special allocations
- No entity election on file
Form 2553 also elects corporate tax treatment for the LLC, so no Form 8832 is needed.
Your profit
Profit rose in 2025 and is projected to rise again in 2026.
2Where the savings come from
At $150,000 of profit, the S corporation saves about $7,320 a year. The PTET election adds about $580, for about $7,900 in all.
Your yearly taxes and costs, from your LLC today to an S corporation
Purple: the S corporation and what it saves youAmber: costs you moreGray: your LLC as it is now
Swipe sideways to see the whole chart.
- −$12,010Social Security and Medicare
As an LLC, 15.3% applies to about 92% of your profit. As an S corporation, it applies only to your $60,000 salary.
- +$1,940Income tax
Your salary doesn't count toward the 20% qualified business income deduction, so that deduction shrinks by about $4,670. The deduction for half your self-employment tax ($10,600) is also replaced by smaller business deductions ($7,340), which adds about $190 of Virginia tax.
- +$2,750Running costs
Payroll service $900, added tax return preparation $1,600, and unemployment taxes of about $250.
- −$580Virginia PTET election
The business pays Virginia's 5.75% tax on its profit after your salary, payroll taxes, health insurance, and costs (about $75,210), so about $4,320, and deducts it on its federal return. You claim a matching refundable credit on your Virginia return. Your income taxes drop about $830, and after its $250 filing cost you keep about $580.
Bonus: your 401(k) deferral saves more tax through payroll. As an LLC, your $24,500 deferral also shrinks your 20% deduction. Through payroll it comes out of your salary, so it doesn't. That's about $1,080 of your savings.
3Your salary: $60,000
Your salary is built from your own hours, priced at what Richmond employers pay for each role.
| Your role | Hours × rate | Share | Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coaching clients and teaching classes | 1,250 hours × $23.12 | $28,900 | |
| Managing coaches, schedules, and members | 500 hours × $22.58 | $11,290 | |
| Running the business: pricing, hiring, and finances | 350 hours × $52.24 | $18,284 | |
| Total | 2,100 hours | $58,474 |
$60,000Rounded up, or $5,000 a month
- Why it holds up: $60,000 is 40% of your profit. Much of the rest comes from your coaches' sessions and your memberships, not your own hours.
- The rates: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Richmond metro area, May 2025. Coaching uses the 75th percentile for exercise trainers because of your 12 years of experience and top-of-market rates. The other two use the median for recreation supervisors and for general and operations managers.
- On file: this table becomes your salary memo, updated each January.
4How the answer changes
The S corporation pays for itself above about $88,000 of profit, and the savings grow from there.
Yearly savings with an S corporation, before the PTET election
Swipe sideways to see the whole chart.
By profit level
Below $88,000
The S corporation costs more than it saves.
$88,000 to $110,000
Savings stay under about $3,000 a year, thin for the extra work. The PTET election only pays for itself above about $112,000.
$125,000 to $200,000
Savings grow about $1,200 for every $10,000 of profit.
Above $200,000
Savings grow more slowly, because as an LLC your Social Security tax already stops at $184,500 of earnings.
Your salary range
Each $10,000 of salary moves your savings by about $1,800.
At $150,000 of profit, before the PTET election. A salary below about $58,000 isn't supported by your hours and roles, and the IRS can treat distributions as wages when a salary is unreasonably low.
5Retirement and Social Security
Your $24,500 401(k) plan fits either way. The S corporation lowers your ceiling and the earnings that build your Social Security benefit.
Most you could put into your 401(k) in a year
Swipe sideways to see the whole chart.
Your ceiling
As an LLC, the business could add up to about $27,880 on top of your $24,500. As an S corporation, up to $15,000 (25% of your salary). To save more than $39,500 a year, we'd raise your salary or revisit the election.
Social Security
The earnings that count toward your future benefit drop from about $138,500 a year to $60,000. That's a real trade-off, and one to make on purpose.
6Your timeline
Decide by November 30 and file in December, so your first payroll runs in January.
- By November 30, 2026
Approve the $60,000 salary and your salary memo. Get payroll quotes.
YouUs - December 2026
- File Form 2553
- Open Virginia withholding and unemployment accounts
- Set up payroll at $5,000 a month
- Adopt a written accountable plan for reimbursements
- Move your health insurance premiums to the business
- Tell your bookkeeper
UsYouPayroll provider - January 2027
First payroll. The IRS acceptance notice (CP261) usually arrives within about 60 days of filing.
Payroll providerUs - Each quarter of 2027
- Payroll returns: federal Form 941, Virginia withholding, Virginia unemployment
- Virginia PTET estimated payments: April 15, June 15, September 15, and December 15
- Your own estimated payments, lowered for the tax withheld from your salary
Payroll providerUs - January 31, 2028
Forms W-2 and W-3, Form 940, Forms 1099-NEC for your coaches, and Virginia's annual withholding return (VA-6).
Payroll providerBookkeeper - March 15, 2028
The S corporation's 2027 return (Form 1120-S), or an extension.
Us - April 17, 2028
Virginia Form 502 and Form 502PTET for 2027. (April 15 is a Saturday.)
Us - April 18, 2028
Your 2027 federal return. (April 15 is a Saturday and April 17 is a Washington, D.C. holiday.)
Us - May 1, 2028
Your 2027 Virginia return, claiming the PTET credit.
Us
The deadline for a January 1 start is March 15, 2027. Filing in December keeps the election and payroll in step. Paying the PTET estimates during 2027 lets the business deduct them on its 2027 federal return.
7What could change this
Four things would make us run the numbers again.
Profit drops toward $110,000
The savings get thin. We'd check again before each January.
You want to save more for retirement
More than $39,500 a year through the business needs a higher salary or a different setup.
A co-owner, a sale, or closing soon
S corporation distributions have to follow ownership, and leaving an S corporation can create tax a sole proprietor wouldn't face.
Your coaches become employees
Virginia presumes people paid for services are employees unless the business can show otherwise under IRS guidelines. That review is separate, and it would change your payroll costs.
Not covered here: sales tax on studio merchandise and Richmond's business license tax. Neither changes with the election.
Winnie
Winnie Jayne | Enrolled Agent-led tax planning and returns
Estimates are based on the information available on the report date and current tax law. Your actual tax may differ, and no specific savings or result is guaranteed.
The numbers in full
| LLC, as now | S corporation | S corporation with PTET | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Social Security and Medicare tax | $21,190 | $9,180 | $9,180 |
| Federal income tax | $10,830 | $12,580 | $11,770 |
| Virginia income tax | $5,380 | $5,570 | $5,550 |
| Unemployment taxes | $0 | $250 | $250 |
| Added costs to run the S corporation | $0 | $2,500 | $2,750 |
| Total | $37,400 | $30,080 | $29,500 |
| Savings compared with the LLC | $7,320 | $7,900 |
| Profit | LLC total | S corporation total | Savings | Savings with PTET |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $80,000 | $15,240 | $16,210 | −$970 | −$1,140 |
| $90,000 | $18,080 | $17,790 | $290 | $170 |
| $100,000 | $20,920 | $19,320 | $1,600 | $1,530 |
| $125,000 | $28,440 | $24,240 | $4,200 | $4,520 |
| $150,000 | $37,400 | $30,080 | $7,320 | $7,900 |
| $200,000 | $55,390 | $42,060 | $13,330 | $14,520 |
| $250,000 | $69,320 | $54,540 | $14,780 | $16,530 |
Assumptions
- Full-year illustration for 2027 using 2026 federal and Virginia rules. 2027 figures will differ slightly; Virginia's 2027 standard deduction, for example, is $9,200. Tax figures are rounded to the nearest $10.
- Profit is before your own pay, health insurance, and retirement contributions.
- Single, no other income. Standard deduction: $16,100 federal; $8,750 Virginia plus the $930 personal exemption. Virginia rates run from 2% to 5.75%.
- Health insurance: $7,200 a year, paid by the S corporation and included in your W-2, then deducted on your return. Following IRS guidance, that deduction also reduces qualified business income under the S corporation.
- Solo 401(k): a $24,500 employee deferral in both cases, with no employer contribution.
- The studio isn't a specified service business, and taxable income stays below the $201,750 level where the 20% deduction can start to shrink.
- Added costs: payroll service $900, added return preparation $1,600 (Form 1120-S and Virginia Form 502), and the PTET return and estimated payments $250.
- Unemployment taxes: federal $42, and Virginia about $200 (the 2.5% new-employer rate plus a small add-on, on the first $8,000 of wages).
- Social Security wage base: $184,500 for 2026. It's $192,300 for 2027, which only matters above about $200,000 of profit.
- Virginia PTET: 5.75%, paid through quarterly estimates during 2027.
Sources: IRS 2026 inflation adjustments, Instructions for Form 2553, S corporation compensation and medical insurance issues, Qualified business income deduction, Section 199A FAQs, One-participant 401(k) plans, Notice 2020-75, Social Security wage base, Virginia pass-through entity tax, Virginia pass-through entities, New Virginia tax laws for 2026, Virginia makes the PTET permanent (HB 29), Virginia Employment Commission tax rates, Code of Virginia § 58.1-8, Code of Virginia § 58.1-390.3, BLS wage data for the Richmond area.